Saturday, May 21, 2011

Who's Your Mommy?

I am a tall person trapped in an average-sized woman's body. It's been very frustrating, especially when I bring things into a dressing room; they are always too long because I have never accepted my small stature and thus choose incorrect sizes. I have spent my life this way, and now that I am getting older and actually shrinking, the problem is worse. I need sympathy, a support group or surgery.

My situation is similar to that of Chaz Bono, daughter of former pop stars Sonny and Cher--and I bet Dad is spinning in his grave these days. Chaz is out there telling his/her story of transformation to all of us spineless shnooks in the TV, Internet, newspaper, magazine and radio audiences who just accepted their original bodies and genders, short stature and all.

It's actually an interesting story, and Chaz is actually a sweet and likable chap/chapette. But still, I wonder, in what way is she/he a man? She was born female and now, in adulthood, has had a double mastectomy, takes male hormones, wears men's clothing and is suddenly referred to as "he." How come--don't you need a penis to be considered a guy?

I also wonder how celebrities expose the most private parts of themselves this way. What is wrong with them--is it brain damage of some sort? I saw a documentary of Chaz when he was still being called Chastity getting his/her boobs removed, lying naked and flabby on the operating table with circles drawn in magic marker around the nipples, whereas I won't be filmed in a bathing suit.

The whole situation is pretty ironic, can we all agree, Cher-wise?

2 comments:

  1. I listened to a podcast of an Oxford University introduction to Philosophy class a while back and was surprised to learn that philosophy is largely the study of the meaning of words. What is "honorable"? What is "honest"? What is "living"?

    So, what is "gender"? Is it only genetics? Is it behavior? Is it identity? Hormone levels? Is gender more than one thing? Who decides and who gets to decide on the definition? And what does it mean for someone to say they are something they are not? What does it mean for them to think they are something they are not? Is there a too far that you can go to be more like what you wish you were?

    Our economic existence is predicated on our willingness to all agree that value can be held in things that have no intrinsic value. Our wealth relies on mass acceptance of some fiction. How much of our social contract relies on similar fictions? Is murder "bad"? Or just risky? Is body shame good? Is someone who decides not to have it insane? Or are they sane?

    Isn't it kind of too easy to just accept that life has purpose or meaning or that there is any value to being or not being? Is the only reason we associate male bodies with male behavior because we always have? Or... not?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Then nothing means anything, right? or maybe it does mean everything. This is the path to insanity for sure...or maybe not!

    ReplyDelete

Big Fat Dummies

Big Mamma  No, it's not your imagination and you don't need new glasses -- store mannequins really have been putting on weight. On a...